• Авторизация


Operation Unthinkable (Churchills Plan for War with the Soviet Union) 01-09-2009 19:33 к комментариям - к полной версии - понравилось!


Within days of the defeat of Germany in World War II, Winston Churchill ordered his war cabinet to draw up contingency plans for an offensive against Stalin that would lead to ``the elimination of Russia'', according to top secret British documents.

The resulting battle plan included the use of up to 100,000 German troops to back up half a million British and American soldiers attacking through northern Germany. It assumed that Stalin would invade Turkey, Greece, Norway and the oilfields of Iraq and Iran in retaliation and launch extensive sabotage operations in France and the Low Countries.

A 29-page report, codenamed Operation Unthinkable, was presented to the Prime Minister on 22 May 1945, 14 days after the end of the war in Europe.

It assumed that the Third World War would start on 1 July 1945, probably with a surprise attack by 47 British and American divisions between Dresden and the Baltic.

The war cabinet plan ruled out ``total war'' against the Red Army, which outnumbered the Allies by more than two to one, adding that there was no reason why an Anglo-American invasion of Russia would fare any better than Hitler's Operation Barbarossa.

Historians had long believed that the tense period immediately after the meeting of the armies of West and East led to plans of this sort, but today's publication is the first proof of their existence.

Professor D.C. Watt, the eminent historian who has written the official history of the British cabinet office in wartime, said it was the first time the papers had been read by anyone other than the principals.

``Nobody has ever seen this kind of thing before,'' he said, ``but we have had strong suspicions that they must have been written.''

The Unthinkable plan was eventually rejected by Churchill on the advice of the Chiefs of Staff and replaced with a defensive scheme to guard against invasion by the Red Army..
 


KEYWORDS:

A bit of what might have been History to chew over for all the armchair strategists out there.

I count myself amongst this lot.

Tony
 

1 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:50 by tonycavanagh

To: jjbrouwer; MadIvan; vooch; Voronin; Travis McGee; Pericles
What might have been.

Tony
 

2 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:50 by tonycavanagh

To: Clive
Any views could it of succeeded
 
3 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:50 by tonycavanagh

To: tonycavanagh
After WWII, the pacifist mathematician, Bertrand Russell, advocated using the atomic bomb against Russia before they obtained it.
 
4 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:50 by Nogbad

To: tonycavanagh
great finding thanks.
 
5 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:50 by green team 1999

To: Serge
What do you think Serge could Russia of taken on a combined American British army.

Tony
 

6 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by tonycavanagh

To: tonycavanagh
The resulting battle plan included the use of up to 100,000 German troops to back up half a million British and American soldiers attacking through northern Germany.

Well, the Germans attacked Russia with over a million men and it did not turn out so well. On the other hand, I am sure American forces would also be coming WEST right after they finished up with Japan
 

7 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by 2banana

To: green team 1999; Nogbad
I hought it would make a change from all the Harry Potter Threads.

I wonder if it has ever been wargamed.

Tony
 

8 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by tonycavanagh

To: tonycavanagh
Maybe it could, maybe not. Don't forget. By this time, our State Department was infiltrated with lots of sympathizers. It could have succeeded if we used the A bomb. At that time, in 1945, we - the United States - was the only one who had it. Russia, with the rest of the world, was in shatters. We could have taken a plane right over Moscow and wiped it out. No more Stalin, etc. Maybe if Harry Truman could have been given a glimpse of the future to come he might have ordered it. Korea, Vietnam, Greece, China, an out of control CIA, JFK, Cuban Missile Crisis, Bill Clinton, Lyndon Johnson, terrorists, the Iran hostage crisis, etc. Most of this happened due to Communism.
 
9 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by 7thson

To: tonycavanagh
There go you Brits trying to steal George Patton's idea.

Whoever thought of it, it was a brilliant plan. It would have saved a lot of global agony all these years.
 

10 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by OK

To: tonycavanagh
Source please?
 
11 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:51 by Captain Kirk

To: tonycavanagh
Patton would have loved this.
 
12 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:52 by Campion

To: tonycavanagh
Tony,

As a wargamer, I can say that this, and just about any other scenario like it has been wargamed.

GLC
 

13 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:52 by GreenLanternCorps

To: tonycavanagh
I think such an attack was strategically possible, but probably not politically survivable. I just don't see how the U. S. or British public would back another war so soon on the heels of defeating Germany.

Assuming political unity, I think the men and material resources of the U. S. and Britain would have been more than a match for the Soviet Union. U. S. and British industry were outproducing the Soviets by far. We would have easily gained and held sea and air supremacy. And remember, we had the bomb by that point. Stalin wouldn't for many more years.
 

14 posted on 17 ноября 2001 г. 0:23:52 by Snuffington

и о каком к черту переосмыслении истории говорить после этого?
для них хорошо и правильно все то ЧТО ВЕДЕТ К УНИЧТОЖЕНИЮ РОССИИ.
вверх^ к полной версии понравилось! в evernote


Вы сейчас не можете прокомментировать это сообщение.

Дневник Operation Unthinkable (Churchills Plan for War with the Soviet Union) | Mihail25 - Mihail25 | Лента друзей Mihail25 / Полная версия Добавить в друзья Страницы: раньше»